When it Comes to Your Cash, Think Safety
Yields are in the cellar, but you don't have to settle for 2%.
By Jeffrey R. Kosnett, Senior Editor
From Kiplinger's Personal Finance magazine, August 2008
- Comments
- Email This Article
- Print This Article
- Order a Reprint
Advertisement
OUR READERS
WHO: Christian and Lori Kuzan, both 40
WHAT: Health-care finance analyst and insurance agent
WHERE: Hamburg, N.Y.
FAMILY: Amanda, 13
SYMPTOM: They need to build a cash reserve and invest it safely
Oh, the joy and the pain. Chris and Lori wed last September and settled into Chris's home with Amanda, Lori's daughter from a previous marriage. Then, in January, fireplace ash ignited in the garage and incinerated the 60-year-old structure. The family now rents an apartment while awaiting completion of a new and larger home.
Insurance erased the old mortgage and other debts, but Chris and Lori are hardly on Easy Street. There's the mortgage on the new house, which will cost $259,000, and all the furniture they need to buy to fill it. Saving for Amanda's education is also a consideration.
MORE PORTFOLIO DOCTOR![]() | |||
|
|
Building Your Own Pension Plan | ||
|
|
Don't Quit Your Day Job Just Yet | ||
|
|
His Risky Picks are Doing Just Fine | ||
The Kuzans have relatively little cash, so Chris is anxious "to recapitalize my life." This will get easier once the Kuzans solve another problem: Lori's old house, located in a depressed suburb of Buffalo, has been vacant since the wedding. Selling the house would free up $900 a month, which could be used for college or retirement savings.
Once Chris and Lori start accumulating some cash, they'll have to determine where to put it. Given today's low interest rates and the credit-market freeze-up over the past year, it's not a simple decision. The turmoil unmasked the risks in ultra-short-term bond funds and bank-loan funds, whose popularity had zoomed because they were perceived as relatively stable investments that paid a bit more than CDs and money-market funds.
Advisers urge young families like the Kuzans to avoid things that could suffer in a weak economy or that own esoteric investments that are hard to understand. Paul Baumbach, of Mallard Advisors, in Newark, Del., prefers ING Direct's savings account, which yields 3.0%, and Vanguard Prime Money Market (symbol VMMXX), which pays 2.2%. Paul LaViola, of RTD Financial Advisors, in Philadelphia, suggests splitting savings between the Vanguard fund and a three-month or six-month CD. Three-month CDs yield as much as 3.0%, while six-month certificates pay up to 3.4%.
Another idea is GE Interest Plus, which combines the extra yield of a short-term corporate bond with such money-market-fund features as checking. "It's like a very short-term bond you can redeem anytime," says Susan Elser, of Elser Financial Planning, in Indianapolis. For accounts of less than $15,000, the yield in mid June was 3.0%. These accounts are not insured, but General Electric is as financially solid as they come.
Of course, Chris and Lori might not want to take any risk with their savings. The good news is that short-term yields aren't likely to go much lower, if at all. And with CDs and money funds, you don't have to fear that a financial conflagration will burn through your cash the way the fire burned through Chris and Lori's house. You can replace a home -- but if you lose your savings, that's another matter.
- Comments
- RSS
Permission to post your comment is assumed when you submit it. The name you provide will be used to identify your post, and NOT your e-mail address. We reserve the right to excerpt or edit any posted comments for clarity, appropriateness, civility, and relevance to the topic.
View our full privacy policy



Reader Comments (9)
Posted by: rc at 07/17/2008 11:07:31 PM
Ford Interest Advantage[uninsured] managed by Ford Credit pays 4% or more depending on balance amount with checking facility.
Posted by: Karen Willoughby at 07/22/2008 10:35:37 AM
These so called advisors are not very knowledgeable. Capitol One Bank and Discover Bank have been offering bank CD's with much better rates for months now. Where have you been? ...
Posted by: Jerry at 07/25/2008 03:01:47 AM
Ummm... A quick search on BankRate.com and you can find FDIC-insured Online Savings Accounts with 3.5% interest rates. Why would you even think of CDs at 3% or less?
Posted by: DLC at 07/26/2008 10:11:10 PM
HSBC Online Savings Account offers 3.5%. Money can be withdrawn anytime. Why go for less as with those in this article?
Posted by: Paul Baumbach at 07/30/2008 08:36:02 AM
As an advisor (who did not mention CDs) quoted in the article, I note that to get 3.5% yield from Discover Bank today, you need to lock in a one-year or longer maturity. That inflexibility does not meet the requirements here.A one-year CD from Discover Bank yielding 3.87% is very good for many purposes, but not as the sole vehicle for emergency cash. The 3.5% HSBC rate is a teaser rate that goes away on 9/15/08.
Posted by: Mark at 08/04/2008 08:13:18 PM
I don't think HSBC's rate is a teaser rate at all. I've enjoyed it for about a year.
Posted by: plainjane at 08/05/2008 01:15:51 PM
They are going to have to pay income taxes on the interest earned on savings accounts and cds, which will reduce the yields even further. What about putting some of their savings into tax exempt municipal bond funds?
Posted by: Paul Baumbach at 08/11/2008 05:28:41 PM
HSBC's site notes that the rate expires on 9/15/2008. Regardless of how long it has been offered in the past, a rate that expires in less than 45 days meets my definition of a teaser rate. A tax-exempt muni bond fund does not meet the emergency cash requirement of stability of principal. A tax-exempt municipal money market does. Two of the largest are Fidelity's (1.83% current yield) and Vanguard (2.07%) At these rates, most investors would find the Vanguard Tax Exempt money market to offer greater after-tax yield than the Vanguard Prime Reserves money market.
Posted by: Hector at 08/23/2008 12:58:54 AM
I would have mentioned HSBC in this article. I'm getting 3.5% and it's been as high as 5.05%. Never below 3% though...